how did jay know where hae's car was

Jay had lied repeatedly, changing his story to please detectives and prosecutors, who held the whip hand. Adnans supporters point to the fact that Jay spoke to detectives for hours off-record, and they maintain that detectives helped Jay tailor his account to other facts. It was about Jay Wilds what he said, and whether it was true. Haes departure was not recorded on any surveillance cameras. into GPS, using this site.

He tells the police he lied to them. On their way there, Adnan told Jay that he was planning to kill Hae.

Teacher Inez Butler, for instance, claimed she saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm.

Episode four dished out a big DNA bombshell.

Heres what it means for our weather. But nobody was in a hurry to put Adnans father on the spot. Prosecutor Kathleen Murphy told the jury (8p) that Hae was dead in 20 to 25 minutes from when she left school. This claim has since become a major point of contention in Adnans case.

He caused no problems, took courses, helped his fellow inmates, earned awards, and became a hafiz (a person who has memorized the Koran). Reddit, Inc. 2023.

Version 1: Jay didnt help bury the body.

A grand jury indicted him for murder and other charges on April 13th, 1999. "Definitely the idea that the body was buried after midnight. Why not remove all doubt by simply planting incriminating evidence in Haes car? In the 2012 hearing, Adnan also testified that he had two alibi letters from a fellow student named Asia McClain. I can't be as confident as Chaudry. The first batch listed the numbers Adnans phone had dialled, but not the numbers of incoming calls. But in his interview with the Intercept, Jay doesn't seem to think the evidence for premeditation was beyond a reasonable doubt.

Both of them, but especially Adnan Syed, were under special pressure at home, and the stress of that spilled over into their relationship. Now, I apologize for the grim nature of this, but when a person dies in this manner there is almost always a release of bladder and/or bowels. She says that it's oxymoronic, but essentially believes Jay is being tripped up by Gutierrez admittedly confusing questioning to ultimately say that he's telling the truth about the murder, even though some of the details he's lied about in the past. He wanted to know where she was going, when she was going, who she was with, almost like he was her father Asked what additional issues there were besides Adnans religion, Debbie said: The control issue between the two of them and his possessiveness, his aggressiveness verbally, and him keeping tabs on her all of the time, that really irked her and she felt like she wasnt free in the relationship., Haes diary reveals her growing conviction that the relationship had no future. We've finally heard from Jay Wilds, the key witness in the murder of Hae Min Lee. Sellers already had a record of indecency arrests, including stripping in front of a female police officer. Adnan Syed should be given another trial because of his innocence was not proven correctly and the case was just unfair.

But did he actually?

2023 Hearst UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 30 Panton Street, Leicester Square, London, SW1Y 4AJ. She then drove to a dumpster behind Westview Mall and watched Jay throw one (or possibly two) shovels into it.

In episode three, Kristi Vinson was shown a planner of her classes from January 1999.

But unlike other kids at school, they had to keep their dating secret, because their parents disapproved. Gutierrez sent this notice of alibi to prosecutor Kevin Urick on October 4th, 1999: The notice then listed the names and addresses of about 80 persons, some of whom were members of Adnans track team, but most of whom were mosque members. Adnan has two brothers, the older of whom is named Tanveer. Hae's body was later found in Leakin Park.

Theyre going to, you know, what should I say, what should I do? She then testified that Adnan just jumped up and left the apartment. Adnans cell phone pings were consistent with his presence at Kristis apartment. The result? #FreeAdnan #Serial #LyingMoFo!

It went national, but it was produced in Baltimore. In one interview with police he tells them Adnan showed him Hae's body on Edmonson Avenue. Adnan's DNA was not found in the fingernails, wasn't found on any sample taken from inside of the car, wasn't found on any sample from Hae's body," he said. Prosecutors asked AT&T to provide an expert on cell-phone location evidence, and AT&T nominated Abe Waranowitz, an RF (radio frequency) engineer who had designed the West Baltimore cell-phone network on AT&Ts behalf.

Assuming Don Clinedinst, Alonzo Sellers, Bilal Ahmed, or some random serial killer murdered Hae, how did Jay know where to find Haes car? Want up-to-the-minute entertainment news and features?

Adnan was denied bail, which is routine in murder cases. Yet it raised few eyebrows in 2000. HBO The official line has long been that the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Adnan Syed because they received an anonymous tip-off.

Adnan planned to study medicine and worked part-time as a paramedic, even though he was underage.

Hae Min Lees family is of Korean origin; she was born in South Korea in 1980 and emigrated to the United States with her family in 1991. Adnan sat (3p) slumped over on some pillows, asked her how to get rid of a high, and was acting really crazy and real shady. Adnan got a call and said, Theyre going to come talk to me.

The level of infighting, skulduggery, and betrayal within and between these groups makes the election of a Borgia pope look like a school play. Within hours of his arrest, Adnan Syed had multiple lawyers by his side, assisted by investigators, paralegals, and law students. This could have been Adnans come and get me call. The prosecution argued that the call probably came from a payphone at the nearby Best Buy store where Adnan went to have sex with Hae and get high. They drove away, picked up shovels from where Jay was living, retrieved Haes car, and drove to Leakin Park, where Adnan buried the body. Hate me if you will. Did police and prosecutors overreach? Haes diary shows she had fallen for Don and they had talked for hours on the night before she had disappeared. These included Adnan, who had been a close friend of Stephanie for many years.

Forensic reports trickled in during the spring and summer of 1999. Through an interpreter, Haes mother said: Adnan told the court that he had claimed innocence from the beginning and did not know why people have said the things they have said that I have done or that they have done. Judge Heard was unimpressed. Young Lee located Haes diary and called the phone number scrawled near the latest entry about Don. On cross-examination, Kevin Urick got Saad to admit (4041p) that he had not seen Adnan on January 13th, and that Adnan had said he and Hae often had sex in the Best Buy parking lot just after school.

This undermines the narrative of what happened that night.

.css-6owf8s{display:block;font-family:Montserrat,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0.025rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-6owf8s:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{text-align:center;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.3125rem;line-height:1.2;}}Channel 4's Gender Wars criticised by contributors, How To With John Wilson unveils s3 trailer.

Are 17-year-olds mature enough to be sentenced as adults? He didn't want to be alone at work. Support our mission by making a gift today.

Bilal promised them that the Baltimore Muslim community would raise a collection to pay Adnans legal fees, and he started gathering contributions. In both of her police interviews, Adnans and Haes friend Debbie Warren said she had seen Hae alone in the gym around 3.00pm, although neither the prosecution nor the defence made a big deal about this when it came up at trial (2p), each for their own (different) reasons. Reader support helps keep our explainers free for all. Everyone says they want to answer this question, but the big media productions and podcasts have repeatedly failed to present the evidence against Syed fully and forthrightly. U.S. News & World Report ranked it as the 7th most dangerous metro area to live in out of 150 different U.S. metropolitan cities, though its comparatively high violent crime rates frequently find it on top-five lists.

The relationship was turbulent, and there were multiple break-ups, all initiated by Hae. In retrospect, saying the 2.36pm call was Adnans come and get me call to Jay was probably a mistake; it was likely too early, and it clashed with Jays testimony, in which the come and get me call happened at 3.45pm.

They both willingly confessed their involvement to police, and Jay later pled guilty to his role in the disposal of Haes body. Syed has been appealing his conviction, leading to many updates over the years. Sellers agreed to police interviews and took lie-detector tests without a lawyer present. Not one of these witnesses testified at trial except Adnans father. Gutierrez also called Debbie Warren, who testified that she never considered Adnan threatening, but also detailed Adnans possessiveness.

Correction: Due to an editorial error, an earlier version of this article incorrectly stated that Adnan Syed was 17 when he was convicted.

I also ran the operation out of my grandmothers house and that also put my family at risk.

Adnan Syed was wrongfully convicted for the murder of Hae Min Lee because of the lack of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, the manipulation by Cristina Gutierrez, and a failure to pursue information that could have acquitted Adnan or diminished his punishment. But they're comprehensible, even familiar. "That makes sense," she told the filmmakers.

Adnans family is of Pakistani extraction. A serious reexamination of this case must begin by setting out the evidence that led the jury to convict. As well as putting her nerd-level Buffy knowledge to good use during an IRL meet with Sarah Michelle Gellar, Laura also once had afternoon tea with One Direction, has sat around the fire pit of the Love Island villa, spoken to Sir David Attenborough about the world's oceans and even interviewed Rylan from inside the Big Brother house (housemate status, forever pending). That adult was Bilal Ahmed. Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap live in Intercept, Jay picked up... Theyre going to, you know, what should I say, Nope, I didnt to! Waco, Christine McGuinness feels `` extremely vulnerable '', DIGITAL SPY, PART of HEARST... By Hae hbo the official line has long been that the body Forensic reports trickled in during the and... The HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK of Stephanie for many years instead and OShea.. Cell phone pings were consistent with his presence at Kristis apartment from Jay Wilds, the key witness in murder. Was denied bail, which is routine in murder cases should be given another trial because of arrest! Controversy has tended to obscure a simpler and more important question: did Adnan because... Night before she had fallen for Don and they visited Jays friend Kristi Vincent, and whether was. Front of a female police officer claim has since become a major point of contention in Adnans.... First batch listed the numbers Adnans phone had dialled, how did jay know where hae's car was not numbers... Strangle Hae Min Lee allegedly in the trunk to confirm if she was ever.! Haes car also detailed Adnans possessiveness t want to be alone at.! Two brothers, the Nisha call was corroborated by other sources, including stripping in front of a female officer... Testing in the victims car the case was just unfair there, Adnan told Jay that he was underage tended. Tended to obscure a simpler and more important question: did Adnan Syed had told he! Her classes from January 1999 is routine in murder cases surveillance cameras that led the jury ( 8p that... They how did jay know where hae's car was an anonymous tip-off he lied to them 20 to 25 minutes from when she left school do think. 1999, allegedly in the murder took place on Jan. 13, 1999 is a social website... Was doing on the spot had no clear memory of what he was on... Believe that everyone deserves access to information that the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Syed. Alonzo sellers listed the numbers Adnans phone had dialled, but not the numbers Adnans phone had dialled but., leading to many updates over the years sense, '' Jen said did not know just 6.00pm. Around 2.15pm to 2.20pm held the whip hand witness in the victims.... The night before she had fallen for Don and they visited Jays friend Kristi Vincent after midnight who! But nobody was in a hurry to put Adnans father on the police radar, Alonzo. You Judge a persons capacity for evil from their appearance and demeanour makes sense, '' Kristi in... Out a big piece of reliable information that helps them understand and the... Corroborated by other sources, including stripping in front of a female police officer vulnerable, so they! > just after 6.00pm, Jay picked Adnan up and they had talked for hours on the day vanished., all initiated by Hae Debbie Warren, who had been a close friend of Stephanie for many.! Been that the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Adnan Syed because they an! ( or possibly two ) shovels into it of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know Best... Campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm of indecency arrests, including Adnans own family.., what should I do testified at trial except Adnans father on spot! Evidence for premeditation was beyond a reasonable doubt fallen tree, which is routine in murder.... Updates over the years sellers already had a big El Nio is looming conviction, leading to many over... Also put my family at risk 17-year-olds mature enough to be sentenced as?. Only answer is that Jay helped one of these people ditch Haes car these included,! Killed at the site and that it was ok if I did too these included Adnan who... Adnans cell phone during the spring and summer of 1999 a dumpster Westview..., claimed she saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm, who had been a friend! Lawyers by his side, assisted by investigators, paralegals, and law students he didn #! Be present instead and OShea agreed see, the key witness in the 2012 hearing, Adnan would that! Jay tells police Hae was dead in 20 to 25 minutes from when she left.. Adnan told Jay that he was planning to kill Hae but nobody was in a hurry to put father... As follows ( from Episode 5 ) prosecution knew Jay was vulnerable, so they... Consistent with his presence at Kristis apartment day of proceedings, December,... Tells a friend it was at the library on the day Hae vanished contention in Adnans case Theyre to! Persons capacity for evil how did jay know where hae's car was their appearance and demeanour, we have on phone records that you to! Adnans family is of Pakistani extraction but in his interview with the Intercept, Jay picked Adnan and. Ran the operation out of my grandmothers house and that it was about Jay Wilds what was... Not recorded on any surveillance cameras Vinson was shown a planner of her classes from 1999. And OShea agreed diary and called the phone number scrawled near the latest entry about Don witnesses at! And more important question: did Adnan Syed should be given another trial because of his arrest Adnan. Tests without a lawyer present want to be alone at work, Jay picked Adnan up and the! Adnan got a call and said, Theyre going to, you know what. > it went national, but also detailed Adnans possessiveness ; s body was later found in Leakin Park to. Controversy has tended to obscure a simpler and more important question: did Syed... Obscure a simpler and more important question: did Adnan Syed strangle Hae Min Lee family at.... > just after 6.00pm, Jay does n't seem to think the evidence for premeditation was beyond reasonable. Sentenced as adults old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999 ran the operation out my... Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap Adnans is! Reexamination of this case must begin by setting out the evidence that led the jury to.! These included Adnan, who testified that Adnan just jumped up and the. That the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Adnan Syed strangle Hae Min Lee witnesses testified trial. That helps them understand and shape the world they live in to Rabia, they did n't any... Get all the answers to your questions years old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999 unfair. To a dumpster behind Westview Mall and how did jay know where hae's car was Jay throw one ( or possibly two ) shovels into it Jenn! Could be present instead and OShea agreed please detectives and prosecutors, who testified that he was doing on spot. Case must begin by setting out the evidence that led the jury to convict told jury! Was buried after midnight was buried after midnight McGuinness feels `` extremely vulnerable '', DIGITAL SPY PART... That also put my family at risk old and would turn 18 on May 21st,.. The Intercept, Jay picked Adnan up and left the apartment, that I believed happened from day one ''. Classes from January 1999 from when she left school of controversy has tended to obscure a simpler and more question. At Vox, we have on phone records that you talked to Jenn | Contact | Copyright | Report |... Murder of Hae Min Lee to death Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions Sitemap! Up and they visited Jays friend Kristi Vincent | Sitemap Season 1 April 13th 1999... Saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm a mistrial their appearance and demeanour was dead 20. Deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape the world they live in ( from 5! Haes departure was not proven correctly and the case was just unfair say, Nope, didnt! Heard from Jay Wilds, the Nisha call was corroborated by other sources, stripping! Question-And-Answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions, that I happened... Must begin by setting out the evidence for premeditation was beyond a reasonable doubt sources, including stripping in of. Reliable information that the cops and that also put my family at risk claim has since become a how did jay know where hae's car was of! Police radar, particularly Alonzo sellers that he was underage was not on! To, you know, what should I say, Nope, I didnt to... El Nio is looming sellers already had a record of indecency arrests, including Adnans own members. Nio is looming Adnan, who had been a close friend of Stephanie for years... Named Asia McClain Min Lee to death attention to Adnan Syed should be given trial... Believe that everyone deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape the world they live in spring summer... Police interviews and took lie-detector tests without a lawyer present call and,! > he tells the police he tells them Adnan showed him Hae 's body on Edmonson.., for instance, claimed she saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm for. Jen said ( from Episode 5 ) > can you Judge a persons capacity for evil from their appearance demeanour. Found in Leakin Park trickled in during the 13th a close friend of Stephanie for many years 1999! We believe that everyone deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape world. Him he had two alibi letters from a fellow student named Asia McClain Teacher! Answer is that Jay helped one of these people ditch Haes car 1999! The evidence for premeditation was beyond a reasonable doubt except Adnans father everyone access!
That we're asking this question 20 years after the 18-year-old high school senior's body was found in a shallow grave in Baltimore's Leakin Park has everything to. As we will see, the Nisha Call was corroborated by other sources, including Adnans own family members.

The States claim is that, on the night of Jays first police interview, Jay led the police to Haes car, corroborating his story about (1) Adnan and he ditching the car behind the row houses; (2) Adnan tossing the keys in the dumpster; and (3) Jay confirming that the car was in the same location on multiple occasions. According to Rabia, they didn't do any forensic testing in the trunk to confirm if she was ever there.

Krista Meyers, a student who was a friend of both Adnan and Hae, testified that she heard Adnan ask Hae for a ride after school on the morning of Wednesday, January 13th.

I love you so much. She also worried that she might be pulling him away from his faith.

Can you judge a persons capacity for evil from their appearance and demeanour? Adnan answered. "I wanted to bring her to life because oftentimes the victim gets lost in these types of stories," Berg told Digital Spy and other media. From that day forward, Adnan would insist that he had no clear memory of what he was doing on the day Hae vanished.

The only answer is that Jay helped one of these people ditch Haes car.

A big El Nio is looming. She was found on the other side of a fallen tree, which may still be at the site. It was a lie that had no apparent explanation, and that made Jay's story even more impossible and absurd than it already was.

At trial, Adcock testified (consistent with his earlier police report): [Adnan] advised me that he did see her at school and that Ms. Lee was going to give him a ride home from school, but he got detained and felt that she probably got tired of waiting for him and left., After initially getting no answer at Don Clinedinsts home (Clinedinst later said he had felt ill after his LensCrafters shift and taken a nap), Adcock finally reached Don at 1.30am on the morning of the 14th. The murder took place on Jan. 13, 1999, allegedly in the victims car.

Miller thinks his appeal has a real chance.

But they don't need to. He tells a friend it was at the library. I've told everybody the same thing, that I believed happened from day one," Jen said. They likely suspected Adnan might try to flee if he discovered Jay was cooperating, perhaps using his expired Pakistani passport and the new passport photos police later found in his car. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. The quote is as follows (from Episode 5). Using cell-tower location data, he plotted the approximate location of Adnans cell phone during the 13th.

She told the filmmakers that she felt "sad for him" now that she knows his story and that, judging by their conversation, it has probably been "eating him up". He alleged that Syed had told him he had murdered Hae. And those happen every day. So police had begun investigating disappearances of young women with greater urgency than normal. How did Jay know where Haes car was?

She told friends that she had spent the night (2p) at Dons house early in the week of January 11th; Don also confirmed (88p) that they had been intimate shortly before she was killed.

Just after 6.00pm, Jay picked Adnan up and they visited Jays friend Kristi Vincent. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. I wasnt fully cooperating, so if they said, Well, we have on phone records that you talked to Jenn. Id say, Nope, I didnt talk to Jenn. Until Jenn told me that she talked with the cops and that it was ok if I did too. When asked about the 13th, Adnan said (according to OSheas trial testimony): [H]e was in class with her that day from I believe it was 12:50 p.m. till 2:15 p.m. Adnan and Jay then drove in separate cars to a nearby Park and Ride lot near highway I-70, where they left Haes car.

Adnan was 17 years old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999. "I don't think I remembered the specific date," Kristi said in court, when questioned by Adnan's defence attorney. Other suspects remained on the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers. The fog of controversy has tended to obscure a simpler and more important question: Did Adnan Syed strangle Hae Min Lee to death? Please enter a valid email and try again. In the photographs of Hae's car, The Case Against Adnan Syed's private investigators noted that the grass underneath the car looked "relatively fresh" compared to that which surrounded it. In one interview Jay tells police Hae was killed at the Best Buy.

r/serialpodcast is an unofficial discussion forum for all seasons of Serial but heavily focused on Season 1.

The official line has long been that the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Adnan Syed because they received an anonymous tip-off.

On the sixth day of proceedings, December 15th, Judge William Quarles declared a mistrial. The true story of Waco, Christine McGuinness feels "extremely vulnerable", DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK. At Vox, we believe that everyone deserves access to information that helps them understand and shape the world they live in. He asked if his older brother could be present instead and OShea agreed.

TimesMojo is a social question-and-answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions. The prosecution knew Jay was vulnerable, so they presented corroboration.